Is Physical Activity Linked to Cognitive Decline?
Background:
Physical exercise has been linked to a reduced risk of
cognitive decline, but most evidence comes from short-term studies, which may
be affected by reverse causation bias. While some research suggests that
physical activity improves cognitive outcomes and reduces dementia risk, the
evidence is inconsistent.
Recent interventional studies have raised concerns about
correlating cognition with physical activity. Moreover, much of the existing
evidence is from observational studies with brief follow-ups and lacks prior
cognitive levels. Modeling cognition as a continuous variable could enhance
statistical power.
About the study: In this meta-analysis, researchers examined
the association between physical exercise and cognitive decline. They evaluated
factors such as follow-up duration, baseline age, exercise amount, and study
quality's impact on the association.
The team searched various databases for relevant records
until November 2, 2022, focusing on observational prospective cohort or
case-control studies involving individuals aged ≥20 years, with follow-up durations
of at least one year. They included studies reporting the associations between
physical exercise and cognition, with validated cognitive outcome measures in
later life (mean and maximum ages of 55 and 65 years, respectively).
Studies assessing physical exercise through devices,
questionnaires, or interviews were included. The primary outcome was the
association between baseline physical exercise and global cognition or specific
cognitive domains at follow-up.
Excluded were studies recording retrospective physical
exercise levels, cardiorespiratory fitness levels, prolonged physical exercise,
and those reallocating for physical exercise. Also excluded were studies using
subjective cognition measures or assessing cognition via disability level
registers, as well as cohorts with baseline dementia, specific diseases, or
cognitive impairments.
Two reviewers independently screened records, assessed
evidence quality, and retrieved data. Disagreements were resolved by a third
reviewer. The team employed random-effects modeling, logistic regressions,
scatter plots, and funnel plots for analysis between January and August 2023,
with final analyses in December of the same year.
Results: Initially, 18,669 records were identified, with 104
records (involving 341,471 individuals) included for analysis. Physical
exercise was associated with reduced cognitive decline or impairment,
particularly in verbal fluency and episodic memory. However, no significant
associations were found in follow-up analyses over ten years.
Physical exercise was related to follow-up global cognition
and its alterations, but no moderation or dose-response associations were
observed. The amount of exercise showed an inverse association with cognitive
decline until 5,000 metabolic equivalents of task minutes each week.
Conclusion: The study suggests a weak but positive
association between physical exercise and cognitive decline, regardless of
cognition level or cohort age. This finding is essential for public health
efforts to delay dementia-related diseases.
Factors such as follow-up duration, rate, exercise
measurement type, and study quality influenced reported associations, with
possible bias detected through funnel plots. Weak associations were observed
between physical exercise and verbal fluency and episodic memory, with mixed
results for executive function between follow-up and change analyses.